Dear Reader,
I love my aunts, but I think they might owe me money. My mom and her two sisters owned a lake cottage together. Our whole family used it for summer vacations over the years, sometimes together, sometimes separately. Mom passed away about six months ago, and I’m her sole beneficiary according to her will. Shouldn’t I inherit a third of the cottage? I haven’t broached the subject with my aunts because I don’t want to seem greedy.
— Potential Propertyholder

Trees are on full autumn display at this cottage on the lake. Photo: Courtesy William Liu
Dear Potential Propertyholder,
Before I answer your question, I want to get an important disclaimer out of the way: I AM NOT A LAWYER! I have never been a lawyer! I have no interest in becoming a lawyer! Sure, I audited an estate law course when I was writing My Parents Are Dead: What Now? I even read the enormous textbook the professor assigned. But that doesn’t make me an attorney, so I can’t give you formal legal advice. I can only give you friendly tips from someone with dead parents who reads textbooks for fun.
Deal? Deal.
Even if I were a lawyer — which, again, I am not — this would be a difficult question to answer without knowing where you live, where the cottage is located, and what kind of property deed we’re talking about. All these factors will shape your approach.
My first instinct? Talk to your aunts directly, assuming you get along with them. It might be an awkward conversation, but given that they’re mourning your mother, too, they likely understand the importance of it. You can play the sympathy card: My mommy is dead, and I’m just a little baby, and I need your help! Or you can use probate court as an excuse: I hate to ask this at such a sensitive time, but for legal reasons, I need to see the property deed for the cottage.
If you’re worried they’ll react poorly, consider bringing in another trusted family member or close friend who can act as a mediator for the conversation. There are even professional mediators you can hire if you have the inclination and the cash. The American Arbitration Association has a mediator search on their website.
If you’re determined to avoid the discussion, then you’re going to have to do some research. I asked John Kohlhepp — certified estate planner and founder of A Secure Plan LLC — what he would do in your situation. You may have noticed that John is also not a lawyer. But John spends his days helping clients close out their loved ones’ estates, and he’s the only person I know who’s more excited about death paperwork than I am.
John suggests seeking out the property deed for the cottage yourself so you don’t have to pay a lawyer to do it for you. Fortunately, property deeds are usually public records. The trouble is knowing where to look for those records. John recommends contacting the county land records office wherever the cottage is located. That might be the county clerk, or the Recorder of Deeds, or some such similar title. Follow the office’s process for requesting a copy of the deed. Once you get your hands on it, you’ll be able to see how the property was held (e.g., joint tenancy with right of survivorship, tenants in entirety, tenants in common).
Here’s where this gets tricky again. Just because you can read the text of the deed doesn’t mean you can interpret the jargon. Let me give you a quick-and-dirty explanation of joint property ownership that is in no way formal legal advice:
Joint tenancy with rights of survivorship: Multiple people own a share of the property, and they don’t have to be equal shares. When one of those owners dies, their interest passes to the surviving owners without probate court.
Tenancy by the entirety: This works only for married couples. Gomez and Morticia own the Addams Family mansion equally, and when Gomez dies, the full title of the property passes to Morticia (or vice-versa, if Morticia predeceases Gomez).
Tenancy in common: Multiple people own a property equally, and when one of those owners dies, their share passes on to whoever they name in their will via the probate process.
Community property: This also only works in the case of spouses, and only in certain states. Let’s say the Addams Family lives in a community property state like California. That means whatever property Gomez or Morticia individually acquires during their marriage automatically belongs to both of them.
Since your mom and her sisters jointly owned the cottage, we can rule out tenancy by the entirety and community property, barring any unusual circumstances. If the cottage is held in joint tenancy with right of survivorship, you WOULD NOT inherit your mother’s share. If your mother and her sisters were tenants in common, you MIGHT inherit your mother’s share.
This is fascinating, isn’t it? I’ll bet you’re glad you asked this question.
Once you have the property deed and you know what type of ownership you’re talking about, you can approach an estate attorney with the appropriate framing, saving you precious billable hours. Thanks for the suggestion, John!
Even if your mother’s estate is relatively simple, I do recommend hiring an attorney in the state where she lived if you haven’t already. It’s not cheap, but the peace of mind is worth it. Ask your friends and family members for recommendations — maybe your aunts? Online reviews are just as helpful for lawyers as they are for hairdressers or restaurants. Talk to a few of them and choose whoever makes you feel the most comfortable. And don’t worry — the lawyer’s fees should come from your mom’s estate, not your own money.
One more thing: Keep in mind that if you do inherit a share of the cottage, it will likely have to be probated in the state where the cottage is located, not necessarily the state where you live, and not necessarily the state where your mother legally resided. Yes, that means you would be dealing with multiple probate processes in multiple states. (And you’d also need to hire an estate attorney in the state where the cottage is located.) Don’t shoot the messenger.
— Reaper
